Two puppy siblings arrived at a New York animal shelter together in search of a fresh start, but after one was adopted in December, the other has been left waiting alone.
The terrier mix puppies, Chris and Peter, arrived at North Shore Animal League America in Port Washington, New York, in October 2025 as part of a transfer from the animal shelter’s partner in South Carolina. The siblings waited together for adoption, but in two months, Peter’s happy ending arrived.
Chris watched his brother leave with a new family in December, Senior Communications Manager Ilene Schreibman told Newsweek. Since then, he’s been waiting for the perfect home, and while he’s received some interest, nothing has panned out.
Despite being a young pup—often a driving factor for adopters—Chris can be shy and fearful, especially around strangers, cowering in the back of the kennel.
“His barrier frustration and anxiety can sometimes be misunderstood as aggression,” Schreibman said. “That said, once he feels safe, especially around trusted people and other dogs, Chris reveals a completely different side of himself: affectionate, playful, and deeply loyal.”
Chris is also up against what is known as “Black Dog Syndrome,” Schreibman said. This is when darker-coated canines are unintentionally overlooked at animal shelters.
Research, however, challenged that notion. Newsweek previously reported that results from a 2023 Cambridge University Press study found both the average length of availability for adoption of black dogs and the rate of euthanasia were not significantly longer or higher than those of canines with other fur colors. But the stigma around black dog syndrome still lingers.
“Combined with his initial shyness, this has likely contributed to his longer stay,” she said.
Building Trust
The shelter is hopeful the right adopter will come for Chris soon, but it will take someone willing to be patient. Schreibman said his future owner will need to be committed to helping Chris build confidence at his own pace, because once he can trust you, he has the potential to be a devoted and loving companion.
“His ideal home would be in a quiet, suburban setting with a fully fenced yard, where he can feel safe and secure,” she said.
The team recommends a household with children over the age of 10, as he needs respect for his space and a structure to settle in.
Adoption Plea
North Shore Animal League America shared his story in a February 4 Facebook post, writing from Chris’s perspective and pulling on heartstrings, as the post reached over 9,200 reactions, 2,600 shares, and 1,300 comments. Part of the post reads: “I watched my brother get adopted, and I’m so happy for him… but I can’t help wondering when it’ll be my turn.”
“Chris is so handsome!!! Wishing and praying he finds a forever home very soon!!!” commented one Facebook user, while another called him a “really cute little rascal.”
A third commenter wrote: “This dog is adorable and deserves the best life ever!”
Those interested in learning more or adopting should visit the North Shore Animal League America website. As the shelter wrote, he had already received a second chance; he now needs someone patient to complete the circle and bring him home.
Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to [email protected] with some details about your best friend, and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.